C-417/ 23 Slagelse Almennyttige Boligselskab Afdeling Schackenborgvænge and Others v MV and Others, [18.12.2025]

Date of the decision: 18 December 2025

Country: Denmark

Jurisdiction: Court of Justice of the European Union

Preliminary ruling

Key facts of the case:

The case also known as the 'guetto case' concerns Danish legislation requiring the adoption of development plans in certain residential areas, with the aim of reducing the proportion of public family housing. These areas were classified, among other criteria, according to whether more than 50% of their residents were ‘immigrants from non-Western countries and their descendants’ over the preceding five years. The implementation of these plans could lead to the termination of existing public housing tenancies.

The Court was asked to clarify whether the criteria used to identify these areas could amount to direct or indirect discrimination on grounds of ethnic origin, contrary to Directive 2000/43/EC.

Outcome of the case:

The Court of Justice (Grand Chamber) ruled that Article 2(2)(a) and (b) of Directive 2000/43/EC must be interpreted as meaning that national legislation requiring development plans to reduce the proportion of public family housing in residential areas where more than 50% of residents are classified as ‘immigrants from non-Western countries and their descendants’ may constitute either direct or indirect discrimination on grounds of ethnic origin.

In particular:

  • Direct discrimination may be established where the national legislation is based on the ethnic origin of the majority of residents in the areas concerned and results in all inhabitants of those areas being treated less favourably than residents of comparable areas where the relevant proportion does not exceed 50%.

  • Indirect discrimination may be established where the legislation, although formulated or applied using apparently neutral criteria, places persons belonging to certain ethnic groups at a particular disadvantage and cannot be justified by the public-interest objective pursued in accordance with the principle of proportionality.

The Court left it to the referring national court to determine whether the conditions for direct or indirect discrimination were met in the circumstances of the case.

Case: CJEU Case C-417/23 – Slagelse Almennyttige Boligselskab Afdeling Schackenborgvænge and Others v MV and Others – Judgment

English
Jurisdiction: 
Court of Justice of the European Union
Subject: 
Discrimination
EU Housing Rights
Country: 

Funders

Subscribe to receive e-mails from us